Well, I wouldn't call it perfect, nothing is. But it's true, this really is the most fantastic WWII game that has ever been released. The replay value is enormous (I can't help but replay the Russian campaign and a few of the various other missions). If you have a 360, this game is essential, it has MY full approval, that's for sure. And as for that whole 'shows us how terrible war is' aspect, I'd say it has that too, especially in the Desert Tank missions. Actually charging the enemy, and so many of you are destroyed. It's a deadly game, the whole war was. In short, sheer brilliance. I'd say at least 93% when it is compared to all other war games, and around 90% compared as an XBOX 360 game.