Questions  Your Reviews  Tips  Polls  Chat View Questions Ask One See Reviews Write One Best | All Tips Give One See Polls Start One View Chat Post One

Harry Potter and related Games, Books, and Movies Warning: May Contain Spoilers for Latest Book Moderated by catahoula and liane forum guidelines  |  forum news

Tip for Harry Potter Provided by: Helmers10 Mar 28, 2007 A Theory for book 7 (Spoilers i guess) This tip is currently ranked 3.0 out of 5 by the first few voters. Helmers10 will earn 3 gems once more people vote! So this theory is about Snape and Draco. Now I am hoping Snape is good in the end but I also thought of something... Now as you should know from Book 6, Chapter 2 Spinner's End, Severus makes the Unbreakable Vow with Draco's mom (can't spell her name lol). He vows to prtect Draco. Now as you read near the end, Draco talks with the wandless Dumbledore. Draco seemed hesitant to carry out his mission and also seemed like he wanted to join the good side although it seems vauge (sp?). So what if he does join the good side? That means Snape (weather he was good or not) will have to join the good side to protect Draco or else he will break the vow, thus killing him..... I hope that isn't completely stupid... tell me what you think please because if it's stupid I would like to know why. Thank you.

So, is this tip helpful? Vote here! Great tips will be ranked higher, and bad tips will be tossed. Please just vote once for each tip (and don't vote for your own tip- we'll know!)...   Pick One:   5 - Simply brilliant and very helpful!!   4 - It's very good and it works!   3 - It's a pretty good tip.   2 - It's a tip, but it's kind of dumb.   1 - I'm just not sure about this one...   0 - It doesn't work!   0 - It's not even a tip!!

There are 6 Replies:
Message	Person and Time
Not necessarily. The task was completed, and Snape can still protect Draco regardless of where he is at. Besides, it’s not in Draco’s character to want to be on the good side. Hopefully we won’t see much of Draco in the final book (maybe a small confrontation), because he isn’t important. I still think your theory has an edge to it. Ultimately, the Unbreakable curse will be Snape’s downfall, but not because Draco joins the good side.	Aly Mar 29, 2007 (420 days and 5 hours ago)
No Snape made 3 vows and here they are exactly as the book says. 1.) "Will you, Severus, watch over my son, Draco, as he attempts to fulfill the Dark Lord's wishes?" 2.)"And will you, to the best of your ability, protect him from harm?" 3.)"And, should it prove necessary... if it seems Draco will fail will you carry out the deed that the Dark Lord has ordered Draco to perform?" Now as you know he agreed to each. The first one can still be broken because Voldemort may have other wishes for Draco to perform. The second vow, is the one I'm talking about. If he betrays Voldemort and Voldemort attacks Draco, especially in front of Snape, he will have to protect him or else he will die. Now 3 doesnt matter because that has been completed unless she was talking about something else but I'm sure she wasn't.	Helmers10 Mar 29, 2007 (419 days and 21 hours ago)
On the contrary, I expect Draco to play a rather large part in the final book. He would seem very important given that Rowling devoted that whole scene to the conversation between him and Dumbledore. I'll bet you that she didn't write that just to take up pages.	Dincuivie Mar 29, 2007 (419 days and 19 hours ago)
Possibly, the situation was just an on-the-moment thing. Dumbeldore wasn't THAT brilliant. And...I don't see how Dumbeldore's death would contribute to the series.	Aly Mar 30, 2007 (419 days and 0 hours ago)
That's a really good theory, it doesn't sound stupid at all, it makes a lot of sense. But I really can't see Snape turning to the good side because he is such a... Um... that's not a word I'm allowed to use on GameTalk. Anyway, the only ones more evil than Snape are Voldy and Umbridge. Yes, I called Voldemort "Voldy." I know how much he hates that. How about this: ... ...... ......... .................... ...... Lord Voldything!	Riddler014029 Apr 1, 2007 (416 days and 18 hours ago)
i think your rigth not about the snape thing but about the whole Draco thing. as i read the books i realized something. Rowlings never puts somthing in one of the books unless it is mant to be there. so why i agree that Draco(no matter how much we hate the Farret) is going to play a big prat in book 7	Harry's Girl Apr 28, 2007 (389 days and 15 hours ago)

Add Your Own Reply

Back to Index