There are 13 Replies:
|
|
Message
|
Person and Time
|
|
Yes. |
|
Yeano
|
Apr 25, 2008
(17 days and 5 hours ago)
|
|
|
This could actually be tested by putting an audio recording device near a tree that is about to fall, and then going away for a while, and then coming back when the tree has fallen. That way you can test whether or not it makes a sound, for those of you skeptics out there. |
|
Yeano
|
Apr 25, 2008
(17 days and 5 hours ago)
|
|
|
everything that falls makes a sound... what object doesnt???? if an object falls and does not make a sound... then thats just weird... i forgot the term but yes a tree does make a sound... its just that it happens when were not around the same time... and please that question is cheezy.... |
|
haduken enix
|
Apr 25, 2008
(17 days and 5 hours ago)
|
|
|
I'll submit the answer of no. Sound only becomes sound once passing through a 'hearing organ', such as the eardrum. Until then, it's merely a vibration in some medium (the ground, the air, whatever). Thus, if NO ONE is around to hear it, the falling tree merely causes a vibration, not a sound. |
|
DeWayne Mann
|
Apr 25, 2008
(17 days and 3 hours ago)
|
|
|
duh, everything makes a sound |
|
.bludthirsty.
|
Apr 25, 2008
(17 days and 3 hours ago)
|
|
|
you should of heard the sound i heard this motionless rock make yesterday, bludthirsty! It was so.....soundy! |
|
Mikau
|
Apr 25, 2008
(17 days and 0 hours ago)
|
|
|
Sound is just a disruption in the air medium. An object falling in the woods would indeed cause a disruption, though you can't hear it. |
|
ScoobyDoo
|
Apr 25, 2008
(16 days and 23 hours ago)
|
|
|
Who said the tree even existed in the first place? "Who controls the past controls the future: who controls the present controls the past." |
|
Qwey
|
Apr 25, 2008
(16 days and 23 hours ago)
|
|
|
Mikau-a rock does make a sound when hit against something else, and some rocks even talk to me.... |
|
.bludthirsty.
|
Apr 26, 2008
(16 days and 6 hours ago)
|
|
|
GTFO with your 1984 quotes. |
|
ScoobyDoo
|
Apr 26, 2008
(15 days and 21 hours ago)
|
|
|
Why does the tape recorder not qualify as someone to hear it? I think it does make a sound. But there is no way to prove this question. Not even with a tape recorder; that's tantamount to a person being there to hear it. |
|
Narrwald
|
Apr 27, 2008
(15 days and 8 hours ago)
|
|
|
you so got that offf mrboxboy123 on youtube,. I hate THAT |
|
ghghgh2323
|
Apr 27, 2008
(15 days and 1 hours ago)
|
|
|
...err, what? |
|
DeWayne Mann
|
Apr 27, 2008
(15 days and 0 hours ago)
|
|